Many Americans Not Benefitting From Strong Economy – ValueWalk Premium
economy Monetary Policy

Many Americans Not Benefitting From Strong Economy


by Gary D. Halbert

June 26, 2018

1. Our Shrinking Middle Class

2. Energy Prices Have Soared Higher

3. Shortage Drives Home Prices Higher

4. Introducing Broadmark Capital

5. Broadmark’s Real Estate Lending Funds

Get The Timeless Reading eBook in PDF

Get the entire 10-part series on Timeless Reading in PDF. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or email to your colleagues.

We respect your email privacy

Q1 hedge fund letters, conference, scoops etc, Also read Lear Capital: Financial Products You Should Avoid?

economy Monetary Policy

geralt / Pixabay


The US economy continues to gain momentum. More and more forecasters are predicting GDP growth of 4% or better for the second half of this year. Yet while the economy is strengthening, many Americans are not fully benefitting from the improvement. Today, we’ll take a look at some of the reasons why.

Following that discussion, I’ll introduce you to an exciting new investment opportunity – Broadmark Capital – which invests in short-term real estate loans to homebuilders and commercial real estate developers. As you will see below, Broadmark’s two real estate funds have delivered very attractive, consistent returns with low drawdowns.

Broadmark’s real estate Funds are restricted to “accredited investors.” An accredited investor is an individual with a net worth of at least $1,000,000 (excluding the value of one's primary residence), or have income of at least $200,000 each year for the last two years (or $300,000 combined income if married) and have the expectation to make the same amount this year.

Let’s get started.

Why Many Americans Are Not Benefitting From the Strong Economy

I have written a lot this year about how the economy is strengthening and how Americans have benefitted from it and will continue to as the recovery gains even more momentum just ahead. However, there are many Americans who are not benefitting as much from the economic recovery, and that’s what I want to talk about today.

Last week after the Fed raised interest rates another quarter point, new Fed Chairman Jerome Powell stated: The economy is doing very well… The outlook for growth is very favorable.” And it is. The unemployment rate has fallen to 3.8% – the lowest since the late 1960's. Cosumer confidence is way up and spending is strong. Household wealth is up. Taxes are down. Factories are busy. Demand for homes is strong.

While these numbers collectively paint a picture of a vibrant economy, they don't reflect reality for many Americans who still feel far from financially secure, even though we are nine years into the economic expansion.

From drivers paying more for gas and families bearing heavier childcare costs to workers still awaiting decent pay raises and couples struggling to afford a home, people throughout the economy are straining to succeed despite the economy's gains.

When analysts at Oxford Economics recently studied American spending patterns, they found that the bottom 60% of earners are essentially having to draw on their savings just to maintain their lifestyles. Their incomes weren't enough to cover expenses. Millions of families still live paycheck-to-paycheck.

Most economists describe the economy as fundamentally healthy, a testament to the durable recovery from the 2008 financial crisis. Yet they also note that even many people who have jobs and are in little danger of losing them feel burdened and uneasy.

Here are some reasons why.

Our Shrinking Middle Class

The net worth of US households and nonprofit organizations rose to nearly $100 trillion in 2017, up $2 trillion last year alone and a new record, according to the Federal Reserve. The problem is, America's wealth is increasingly lopsided, with the affluent and ultra-wealthy amassing rising proportions of the total net worth and everyone else benefiting only modestly, if at all.

Strong Economy

The top 10% of the country holds 73% of its wealth, a share that has crept steadily up since 1986, according to the World Inequality Database. The most sweeping gains are concentrated among the top 1%, which holds nearly 39% of the wealth, and they're arguably poised to become even more prosperous in the future.

Contrast that with the middle 40% of the country, a group that would historically be considered “middle class.” In 1986, they held 36% of the country's wealth; now, it's just 27%. So in terms of wealth, the middle class is shrinking. Worse off is the bottom 40% of Americans, most of whom have a negative net worth and almost no financial cushion in case of an emergency.

Most Americans can't draw on stocks, rental properties, capital gains or significant home equity to generate cash. They depend almost exclusively on wages. And after adjusting for inflation, the government reported that Americans' average hourly earnings have barely budged over the past 12 months, up only 2.7%.

Energy Prices Have Soared Higher

Even with inflation running at a relatively low 2.4%, one particular expense is weighing on anyone driving in traffic or commuting to work. Gasoline prices have surged 24% over the past year to a national average of $2.94 a gallon, according to AAA. That's the highest average since 2014.

Analysts at Morgan Stanley have estimated that the increase this year will likely eat away a third of people's savings from President Trump's tax cuts. While gas prices are still below their high reached roughly a decade ago, the increase this year represents an additional financial burden on consumers and businesses compared with a year ago.

Childcare Costs Are Accelerating

Children are immensely expensive. For nearly a third of families, the costs of childcare swallowed at least 20% of their annual income, according to a survey posted in March by the caregiver jobsite Nearly a third of parents said they went into debt to cover childcare expenses.

When assessed how much its members were spending on daycare centers for infants yearly, the average cost was $10,486, and it ranged as high as $20,209. Nannies were even more expensive.

Some women remain outside the workforce because of the comparatively weak family leave and child care policies in the US relative to those in other developed economies. As a result, many families are forgoing income that would otherwise benefit them and the economy.

When the unemployment rate was last below 4%, the proportion of women who either had a job or were looking for one was peaking. For women ages 25 to 54, that proportion – called the labor force participation rate – was roughly 77% in 2000. It's now down to 74.8%.

Shortage Drives Home Prices Higher

A strong job market can actually be a curse for would-be homebuyers. With more people drawing paychecks and able to afford a home, demand has intensified. Yet the number of homes listed for sale is flirting with historic lows. The combination of high demand and low supply has driven prices to troubling high levels.

It's not just that home ownership is largely unobtainable in big cities. The real estate brokerage firm Redfin says the median sales price in the 174 markets it covers has jumped 6.3% over the past year to $305,600.

A general rule of thumb is that buyers can afford a home worth roughly three times their income. So, the median home sales price far exceeds what a typical US household earning a median $57,000 income can manage. As noted above, average hourly wages have risen just 2.7% over the past year.

On top of that, 30-year fixed-rate mortgages are growing costlier. The average interest rate on these mortgages jumped to 4.62% last month – up from 3.95% at the start of the year – according to mortgage buyer Freddie Mac.

These are just a few of the reasons why many Americans are not fully benefitting from the strong economic recovery.

Introducing Broadmark Capital

While this red-hot real estate market may not be good news for those looking to buy a new house, it has provided a lot of great opportunities for homebuilders and investors. We recently discovered a money manager that has been able to consistently take advantage of this strong real estate market – Broadmark Capital.

Broadmark writes short-term, first deed of trust mortgages (generally less than a year). Many of these loans are to homebuilders and builders of condominiums or apartments, which as you just read are in short supply. They need this short-term financing to fund the construction of the properties they are building.

The opportunity to write these loans exists because after the financial crisis that ended in 2009, many regional banks that builders traditionally relied on for short-term lending stopped making these types of real estate loans. Many of these banks have been slow to resume this type of lending, if at all.

In addition, increased regulations under Dodd-Frank had a disproportionate negative impact on regional banks. It made it more difficult for many of them to make these types of loans. Plus, after the crisis ended, many of them still had too much real estate exposure on their books.

Broadmark started their first fund in August 2010 shortly after the credit crisis ended. They have been able to capitalize on these types of loans ever since, with over $400 million in assets under management.

Broadmark’s Real Estate Lending Funds

Broadmark’s Funds include the Pyatt/Broadmark Real Estate Lending Fund I and the Broadmark Real Estate Lending Fund II. These two Funds do not use leverage since leverage can increase risks, especially in the event of an economic downturn.

They have a maximum 65% Loan to Value ratio. This means if the real estate securing the note is worth $1,000,000, they would only loan up to $650,000 to the borrower. This helps to reduce the risk the Funds incur in making these loans.

They also use a very thorough underwriting process they’ve developed before they approve any loans. This includes obtaining a credit application, financial statements, a personal guarantee from the borrower, along with their personal financial statements and tax returns – plus an independent appraisal of the property, among other items.

Their goal is to provide a high-yield debt investment while minimizing
the risks of principal loss and maintaining near-term liquidity.

Broadmark’s Funds have been able to capitalize on this opportunity to provide short-term financing to builders and provide attractive and consistent returns to their investors.

Their track record is very impressive with an average
annual return of about 10% (net of fees and expenses).

Broadmark manages funds that focus on different geographical areas of the country. The Pyatt/Broadmark Real Estate Lending Fund I writes loans in three states – Washington, Oregon and Idaho. Its track record has been very consistent and spans nearly 7½ years.

Download the Pyatt/Broadmark Real Estate Lending Fund I Fact Sheet

The second fund, Broadmark Real Estate Lending Fund II, makes loans in Colorado, Utah and Texas and has a consistent track record of nearly 4 years. Broadmark believes these two regions have strong economies and offer good potential for growth.

Download the Broadmark Real Estate Lending Fund II Fact Sheet

These are real returns, net of all fees and expenses. Both Funds are independently audited annually. As always, past results are not necessarily indicative of future results and there is a risk of loss. See the Confidential Offering Memorandum for more details.

These Funds have over $400 million in assets under management. Broadmark’s management has written almost 800 real estate loans in their Funds. The minimum investment is $100,000 and there is a one-year lock-up. After that, redemptions are permitted at the end of each quarter.

You should seriously consider Pyatt/Broadmark Real Estate Lending Fund I and Broadmark Real Estate Lending Fund II for your portfolio if you are an accredited investor. In fact, I believe these two unique Funds, which are uncorrelated to stocks and bonds, should be core holdings for most accredited investors.

Plus, with all the volatility in the markets recently, now may be a great opportunity to diversify your portfolio.

If you are an accredited investor, but you have not told us you are, use this simple form to let us know. We can then share information with you on investments that are restricted to accredited investors. And remember, we NEVER share your financial information with anyone!

Finally, we also have similar real estate funds that are available to non-accredited investors. There are three successful funds you can look at here.

Call us at 800-348-3601 if you would like to learn more about any of these funds. You can also e-mail us for more information at

All the best,

Gary D. Halbert


How Shrinking Middle Class Affects the Housing Market

Hulbert: Current Dip in Stocks Could be Buying Opportunity

Democrats Face Population Losses in High Tax Blue States

Gary's Between the Lines Blog: Foreigners Are Already Reducing Holdings of US Debt



Saved Articles

Here’s a Tip: Read What Professional Investors Read

ValueWalk Premium is for investors looking to improve their investment process AND keep up-to-date on the latest industry trends.

It’s THE resource for value investing and hedge funds. 📈

And with a free three-day trial and $29.99 per month thereafter, it’s a value in its own right.

Sign up now. 👇