Charlie Munger

PharmaCielo: 100% Downside on Co-Founder’s History of Securities Fraud Allegations: Hindenburg Research

PharmaCielo: 100% Downside on Co-Founder’s History of Securities Fraud Allegations, Numerous Undisclosed Related Party Transactions and Operational Failures

Q4 2019 hedge fund letters, conferences and more

Summary: PharmaCielo (TSXV:PCLO / OTC:PCLOF)

  • We believe PharmaCielo is nothing more than the latest self-enrichment scheme drummed up by its co-founder Anthony Wile, who had been charged by the SEC over allegations of securities fraud, stock promotion and market manipulation in the past.
  • Wile co-founded PharmaCielo just prior to finishing serving a 5-year officer and director bar that he consented to in 2010 as part of a settlement stemming from the SEC charges.
  • Unbeknownst to investors, PharmaCielo’s key operating property in Rionegro, Colombia was purchased through a bankrupt company co-founder (Federico Cock-Correa) via a Panamanian entity linked to Anthony Wile. It was then sold to PharmaCielo at a massive markup, allowing insiders to enrich themselves by an estimated $5.35 million by stepping in the middle.
  • The company announced it was building greenhouse facilities on newly-purchased land in Colombia’s Cauca region in 2017. We visited the land and found the greenhouses don’t exist. The site is nothing more than an empty field covered in weeds. (We have photos and video)
  • PharmaCielo recently announced a U.S. distribution deal with an opaque company called General Extract LLC. We found that this is yet another undisclosed related party deal, involving PharmaCielo’s former COO. General Extract’s parent company corporate address (“Suite D-357”) was actually a mailbox at a Colorado UPS store.
  • PharmaCielo’s other main partnership, a distribution deal with nanocap company XPhyto, appears to be little more than a shell game. PharmaCielo is supplying XPhyto with cash so XPhyto can turn around and buy PharmaCielo’s products.
  • The company is running low on cash, with an estimated $11.7 million remaining. We believe the company’s back is against the wall and, accordingly, expect a dilutive capital raise in the near future.
  • The company’s Rionegro cannabis oil processing centre, a key element of its plan to export oils, remains unfinished after almost 6 months of delays.
  • According to local sources, the Rionegro greenhouse facilities have issues with mold and residual pesticides from the flower-growing operation that preceded the company’s use of the facility.
  • Co-founder Anthony Wile has been hitting the bid recently, dumping 200,000 shares of his then 13 million shares of the company just days before PCLO’s CEO issued a shareholder letter telling investors that insiders were “confident holders”.
  • PharmaCielo has property, greenhouses, licenses, and some residual cash. But with essentially no revenue, continued cash burn, and management’s track record of self-enrichment and the co-founder/former CEO’s history of securities fraud charges, we believe PharmaCielo ends up as a total loss for investors.

Initial Disclosure: After extensive research, we have taken a short position in shares of PharmaCielo through PCLOF, its U.S. OTC ticker. This report represents our opinion, and we encourage every reader to do their own due diligence. Portions of our research for this report required on-the-ground conversations with locals in Colombia. Given the volatile nature of the political climate in the country, we have removed several source names from the report. However, those names can and will be made available to regulators and/or government entities upon request. Please see our full disclaimer at the bottom of the report.

Background: Basics on the Company and the Bull Thesis

PharmaCielo trades on the TSX Venture exchange and U.S. Over-the-Counter Market (“OTC”) under the symbols PCLO and PCLOF, with a market cap of roughly $200 million as of this writing.

The company describes itself as focused on cultivating, processing and supplying all-natural medicine-grade cannabis oil extracts to large channel distributors via its greenhouse facilities in Colombia.

PharmaCielo’s Colombian operating subsidiary owns 2 properties:

  1. 12 hectares of open-air greenhouses and a processing & extraction facility situated on a 27 hectare property in Rionegro.
  2. A 3.6 hectare property in Northeastern Cauca, where PharmaCielo has a contract-production partnership deal with a 63 person cooperative called “La Cooperativa Unidad del Norte” (aka Caucannabis)

PharmaCielo has generated only $60,843 in cannabis revenue throughout the life of the company [Pg. 3], but the bull thesis seems to focus on:

  • PharmaCielo’s first-mover advantage in Colombia;
  • Its ability to eventually become a low-cost producer of cannabis; and
  • Its ability to monetize both its existing facilities and expand through different cooperative farming deals.

The company has greenhouses that are currently growing cannabis in Rionegro, as corroborated by photographs taken last week as part of a touring of its facilities by the Colombian Justice Minister:

Sell side reports tout the company’s “multi-year supply agreements” in the U.S. and Europe as key selling channels.

Cormark Securities (which underwrote the company’s August 2018 financing and advised on a prospective acquisition) has consistently rated the company a “buy”. In Cormark’s research initiation, it specifically touted PharmaCielo’s management team as a key strength:

PharmaCielo

(Source: Cormark Securities, “Buy” Initiation report dated May 31, 2019)

Reality Check: Multiple Undisclosed Related-Party Transactions with Insiders, Supply Agreements with Apparent Shell Companies, ‘Greenhouse’ in Cauca Region is an Empty Field, Co-Founder Previously Targeted by SEC and an Imminent Need for More Capital

Our research, which has included extensive, on-the-ground research in Colombia and in the U.S., has revealed to us that the company’s prospects differ sharply from management’s narrative. Through our research, we found:

  1. The co-founder and former CEO of PharmaCielo has a track record of securities fraud, according to SEC allegations. He settled the charges in 2010, agreeing to a 5-year ban from being an officer or director of a public company. He co-founded PharmaCielo while still barred as a public officer/director, then took it public shortly after the ban expired.
  2. The company’s key Rionegro Colombian facility appears to have been purchased in an undisclosed related party transaction though PharmaCielo’s bankrupt co-founder. Insiders enriched themselves by first purchasing the rights to the property into a newly-formed Panamanian entity (set up 3 DAYS prior to the deal), then re-sold it to the company at inflated prices, pocketing an estimated $5.35 million by stepping in the middle.
  3. The company’s key 3.6 hectare ‘operation’ in Colombia’s Cauca region is actually just an empty field (we have pictures and video). We confirmed this with local leaders of a farming co-op that struck a deal to grow cannabis with the company.
  4. PharmaCielo disclosed paying over $865,000 for the land in Cauca, including 201,000 shares. Yet local land records show that the Cauca land was sold for only ~$127,000. Co-op leaders confirmed the price and stated that they received no shares as part of the transaction. We hypothesize that the ‘missing’ money may have yet again found its way to insiders.
  5. The company’s odd acquisition of a telemedicine platform appears to have been part of a quid pro quo where (a) PharmaCielo bought the company from an investor in exchange for (b) the investor allocating money to a different company founded by a PharmaCielo co-founder.
  6. The company’s U.S. distribution partner is actually yet another undisclosed related-party deal with a company that appears to have limited to no credible operations.
  7. PharmaCielo has generated only $60,843 in cannabis-related revenue despite years of development.
  8. As it appears a large amount of money has gone to enrich insiders, the company likely needs cash imminently in order to maintain operations and complete its oil processing facility, a key component of its plan to export cannabis oils.
  9. The company’s main facility in Rionegro may be troubled with mold and pesticide contamination, likely originating from the flower-growing operation that preceded PharmaCielo’s assumption of the facilities, according to local sources we spoke with. In addition, Rionegro planning authorities say one-third of the land is unusable due to environmental restrictions and the risk of flooding.

We have a 1-year price target of $0 based on the company’s lack of meaningful revenue ($130k since inception), continued losses, whittling cash (estimated at $11.7 million as of this writing) [1] and incredibly questionable management behavior.

Leadership: PharmaCielo’s Co-Founder, Former CEO and “Backer” Anthony Wile Had Previously Been Accused by The SEC of Stock Manipulation. We Think He’s Back at It Again.

They say the tone is set at the top. PharmaCielo’s co-founder, largest shareholder, “backer” and former interim CEO/Director, Anthony Wile, has a history of stock manipulation and pump and dumps, according to SEC prosecutors.

Anthony Wile listed himself as co-founder of PharmaCielo Ltd. on his recently-deleted LinkedIn page (that disappeared during the course of our investigation, around February 24, 2020. We archived it on February 2, 2020.) On the same page, he stated that he had been involved in PharmaCielo’s operations since the company was established, which was in 2014.

He listed his work experiences dating back to 2007, but he left out this key detail from earlier in his career:

PharmaCielo

In 2007, Wile was listed as a defendant in a civil injunctive action filed by the Securities and Exchange Commission, which alleged that he issued deceptive press releases, promotional materials, and created a misleading website to tout a publicly-traded mining company. Wile was also accused by the SEC of “orchestrating touting”, a “manipulative stock trade on the open market to create an inflated market” and disseminating “materially false and misleading information to the market.”

As a result, the SEC sought a permanent bar to prevent Wile from serving as an officer or director of any public company, but Wile settled the SEC charges in 2010 for a 5-year ban and a civil penalty of $35,000.

Before the ban ended in 2015, however, Wile was already on to his next project, co-founding PharmaCielo in 2014.

Leadership: PharmaCielo’s Other Co-Founder and Former CEO/Director Federico Cock-Correa Was in the Midst of Bankruptcy Proceedings Upon His Recruitment to The Company

Aside from Wile, Federico Cock-Correa is a company co-founder, former CEO of PharmaCielo Holdings (the Colombian operating entity) and current board member of PharmaCielo Colombia. Cock-Correa has a background in horticulture and has previously owned and operated flower and greenhouse businesses in Colombia’s northwest Antioquia province.

According to our research, Cock-Correa was experiencing a period of severe financial distress during the time he linked up with Anthony Wile. One local source told us the following:

“At PharmaCielo one of the founders brought in a bankrupt flower grower. That was the first mistake. They also made a mistake in the area they chose.”

Colombian corporate records corroborate this. The current name for Cock-Correa’s key flower growing business on its incorporation certificate is “Tahami y Cultiflores SA En Reorganizacion” [In Reorganization]. The certificate shows the company formally agreed to a restructuring deal (broadly equivalent to U.S. Chapter 11 Bankruptcy proceedings) on June 6, 2014.

But the problems stretch back much earlier, to at least 2011, with court insolvency rulings, and bank embargos on Tahami’s greenhouse facilities.

Cock-Correa and his family continue to run Tahami and are still paying off their debts. Under the terms of the insolvency deal, the debt repayments run for a 10-year period (2014-2024). Creditors include two banks, pension funds and the government tax agency.

Critically, none of this seems to have been disclosed to investors. On the contrary, PharmaCielo’s filing statement from January 2019, the foundational document detailing the business and its risks, states unequivocally that no director or officer of the Resulting Issuer (PharmaCielo), had been acting as the representative of any company that had become bankrupt or subject to any insolvency proceedings within the past 10 years: [Pg. 76-77]

PharmaCielo

This appears to be a major misrepresentation. Cock-Correa had a company that became insolvent and had been in reorganization prior to the filing, during the date of the filing, and is still to this very day.

Furthermore, the bankruptcy is inexorably linked to PharmaCielo. Prior to PharmaCielo’s purchase of the Rionegro property, Tahami had operated the very same property since as early as 1992, per this filing we pulled from the Rionegro Chamber of Commerce:

Both companies even operated side-by-side on the same premises during 2016, according to company registration documents. [1,2]

A local source confirmed to us that Wile helped financially support Cock-Correa during his insolvency period. The financial support does not appear to have been an act of charity, however.

Undisclosed Related Party Transactions: The Company’s Key Property in Rionegro, Colombia Was Bought Through PharmaCielo’s Co-Founders

When looking into the company’s key greenhouse facility in Rionegro, we came across the first of several instances of apparent insider self-dealing involving either Anthony Wile or Federico Cock-Correa, the company’s co-founders.

Central to almost all of PharmaCielo’s business ambitions is the company’s “headquarters and principal cultivating facility” in Rionegro, Colombia which the company touts on its website, in press releases and is often referenced in analyst reports about the company.

The company announced the purchase of the site in July of 2016, per this press release, which called it a “significant milestone”, and disclosed that the company paid $5.02 million in cash and 1.7 million in equity shares for the purchase, equating to a total estimated purchase price of $8.85 million.[2] The deed was signed on June 1, 2016, one month earlier.

We checked local land registry documents and found that the total land sale (which consisted of two parcels, with the second sold on August 30, 2017) cost only about $3.5 million USD. [Plot 1, Plot 2] This was a wide discrepancy from the value that PharmaCielo had announced in its press release ($5.02 million in cash and 1.7 million equity shares).

We had our Colombian investigator look into the deal further. What we found was that the property was bought in what appeared to be an undisclosed related party transaction through PharmaCielo’s co-founder, Federico Cock-Correa.

Local real estate records [1,2] show that the property was owned by four siblings with the surname Uribe Villegas. Our investigator consulted two of the prior sibling owners by phone, in February 2020. Neither would confirm the purchase price, but one (Pedro Javier Uribe) directly contradicted the PharmaCielo press release that indicated the purchase included 1.7 million in shares:

“We received payment in cash. Maybe we got something like 3 percent of the value of the farm we got in shares. But 1.7 million shares? No, no no, no. That’s a lot. No we got much less.” (Note that we have this conversation on audio.)

Read the full report here by Hindenburg Research


X
Saved Articles
X
TextTExtLInkTextTExtLInk

The Life and Career of Charlie Munger

Charlie is more than just Warren Buffett’s friend and Berkshire Hathaway’s Vice Chairman – Buffett has actually credited him with redefining how he looks at investing. Now you can learn from Charlie firsthand via this incredible ebook and over a dozen other famous investor studies by signing up below:

  • Learn from the best and forever change your investing perspective
  • One incredible tidbit of knowledge after another in the page-turning masterpiece of a book
  • Discover the secrets to Charlie’s success and how to apply it to your investing
Never Miss A Story!
Subscribe to ValueWalk Newsletter. We respect your privacy.

Are you an intelligent investor?

ValueWalkPremium is a website and newsletter for smart investors like yourself. We focus on the latest hedge fund industry news much of which is not in the public domain and obtained via our sources.

We also have 10 years of resources on how to use this information to better your investment process.

Sign up for  today for only a few dollars a day and get a 3 day no obligation trial with a targeted 20% discount coupon code.

Cancel anytime during trial and you are never charged.

Limited time offer: For first 50 subscribers

0